There have been a handful of reports recently about women defending themselves against attackers. Unfortunately, far from applauding these women and thanking them for their help in bringing a criminal to justice, law enforcement professionals seem to be encouraging a culture of victimhood.
On May 5, 2010, a female college student was being attacked by a man with a knife. 5 other female college students saw the attack, and overpowered the attacker.
Police Sgt. Paul Edwards told the Bangor Daily News, “We would never recommend getting involved to the point where you might get hurt yourself and become a second victim.”
This flies directly in the face of discussions concerning making it illegal to walk by a crime in progress. Sgt. Edwards is promoting selfishness over self-sacrifice, and callously allowing others to become victims. So much for serve (others) and protect (others). Sgt. Edwards seems to be promoting “serve yourself and protect yourself.”
At least Sgt. Edwards had the decency to add, “But am I proud of what they did? Of course I am. Am I glad they did it? Yeah. I’m happy because the outcome was good.”
Australian law enforcement apparently didn’t even have that decency, when they were quoted as saying “not that we encourage that sort of thing” when a female Karate black belt defended herself against a would-be assailant.
If law enforcement officials would prefer we leave our defense “to the professionals,” I’d also like to point out that the woman attacked in Bangor, Maine had a restraining order against her assailant. Where were the professionals when he violated that piece of paper and came at her with a knife? If civilian passers-by had not intervened, this would probably be a murder case instead of assault. The professionals simply weren’t there.
Modern society, apparently including law enforcement professionals, need to recognize that self defense is a fundamental right and responsibility of every person. Unless police are going to take up 50% of the population and assign a professional bodyguard to every person, it’s impossible for them to be there to defend someone at the critical moment. Even a 5-7 minute response time may be too late.
I call on our government officials, especially those directly tied to law enforcement, to promote a culture of personal responsibility and self defense. Should we rely on the professionals whenever possible? Definitely. They have more training and a better knowledge of the law than we do. On the other hand, we all need to take responsibility for our own defense until a professional is available.